Originally know as the “Tannersville Cottage” became “The Mansion House”-a large building reaching from 5981 to 6009 Main St. (Stretching to the current Last Chance Cheese Restaurant). It was eventually torn down in the 1930s. After, Mr. Edward Raensch built a garage and gas station. It later became “Garrisons Sporting Goods”, followed by Sharon Leach’s “J Tree”.

The Hunter Foundation purchased the building in 2015. The building underwent minor repairs receiving a new coat of paint and interior renovations.

The two apartments were renovated and are now occupied by year round tenants. The new storefront is Kaaterskill Liquors, open seven days a week.